CapitalWorks

  • Who We Are
    • About CapitalWorks
    • CapitalWorks Team
      • Richard Hollington
      • Robert McCreary
      • Todd Martin
      • Mikel Harding
      • John Corrigan
      • Matthew Lombardo
      • Ryan Zeccola
      • Patrick Chang
      • Jennifer Haberman
      • Kellie Work
      • Andrea Zacher
    • Investor Participation
      • Industry Council
      • CapitalWorks Advisory Board
      • Portfolio Company Boards
    • Why Invest with CapitalWorks
  • Criteria
    • Acquisition Criteria
    • Why Sell to CapitalWorks
  • Portfolio
    • Current Portfolio
      • Advanced Hydro Solutions
      • Bancsource
      • Capewell Aerial Systems
      • Chemtron Corporation
      • GEMCITY
      • Paradigm
      • Ripley Tools
    • Locations Map
    • Exited Portfolio Companies
  • News
    • CapitalWorks News
    • Portfolio Company News
      • Advanced Hydro Solutions
      • Capewell
      • Chemtron Corporation
      • Paradigm Window Solutions
      • Ripley Tools
    • PE4Fams Blog
  • Contact Us

PE4Fams Blog

Insurers Underwrite LBO Risk

September 26, 2018 By Rob McCreary


Five years ago, when a private equity firm sold a business the buyer would require the seller to establish a funded escrow account (5-10% of the purchase price) with an independent bank as a convenient source of indemnification for representations and warranties. Until recently, in the lower middle market, it was highly unusual for a third-party insurer to underwrite and insure that indemnification obligation.  In a recent survey by GF Data (September 2018) the prevalence of representation and warranty insurance is notable:

“Use of an insurance product continued to rise, from 43 percent of all deals in 2017 to 47.3% in the first half of 2018. At $50-250 million TEV, the jump was from 66.7% to 69.7%.”

” Valuations remained at historically elevated levels on deals utilizing insurance – maintaining an average mark of 7.7x. The average multiple fell, however, on deals completed without insurance – from 7.1x to 6.4x. Average indemnification caps rose slightly across the board in the first six months of this year.”

Data Rooms Become The Underwriters’ File

We utilized our first indemnification insurance product in a sale in December 2013. At that time the number of insurers who were willing to underwrite a smaller transaction was limited. Today there is competitive interest from many insurers in transaction sizes $20 million and larger. It shows the maturation of the private equity industry and the comfort underwriters have for PE due diligence. Partly this is attributable to data rooms where 100% of the due diligence information for a transaction is posted to a data repository that, in essence, then becomes the insurance company’s underwriting file. Sellers and buyers often split the costs of this insurance policy and the retention, which works like a deductible on your homeowner’s policy, is usually also split. In the competitive M&A markets right now, it is also becoming more common for the policy to be structured so there is zero recourse against the seller in competitive auctions.

In addition to underwriting the data room file, the insurer looks at the reputation of the parties to the transaction, the quality of their advisors and the independence of the various “experts” who report on quality of earnings, environmental matters, human resources, health and safety and wage and benefits. Because the insurer is stepping into the shoes of the seller for any major indemnification claims, there are often specific matters where there is known risk that are excluded from the policy. That might mean that a known environmental cleanup responsibility remains 100% with the seller or responsibility for existing litigation is not insured.

Third Party Insurance Fits The PE Model

The nature of private equity with finite fund lives and relatively short investment periods lends itself to a third-party stepping in. There was always a great temptation for a disappointed buyer to invent a series of claims against the indemnity escrow after the closing simply to reduce the purchase price. Now the insurer bears a large portion of that post closing responsibility and has both the time and infrastructure to dispute buyer claims. A private equity firm was more likely to compromise a bogus claim because of time, legal costs and fund life considerations.

According to Jeff Phillips, Vice President and Practice Leader of Transactional Risk for Oswald Companies  who were early advocates of “reps and warranty insurance” for the lower middle market, the claims administration process has also been professional and reliable:

 “Twenty percent of Reps and Warranties polices are going on claim with issues arising most frequently from Financial, Tax, Compliance with Laws and Material Contracts.  Generally, our clients have been pleased with the claims administration process and the insurers understand that for this product to be viewed as an attractive alternative to traditional seller indemnification, valid documented claims must be paid promptly.”

These Policies Are Affordable

The other surprise about this insurance product is affordability. The typical premium for $5.0 million of coverage in a clean $50 million transaction with a deductible of 1% of the purchase price might only be $150,000-175,000 depending on the industry. This suits a private equity firm that can then operate with certainty about its ongoing contingent liabilities for portfolio companies that have been sold. This usually means quicker distributions to fund investors and general partners.

The ultimate test of this product will come when there is the next recession. Highly indebted companies with shrinking cash flows and earnings may look to insurers for help through indemnification claims. It will be interesting to see how well the insurance industry has really underwritten its risks. My prediction is this product will do better than the underwriters expect largely because the reps and warranties made by sellers get diluted by the auction environment in which each buyer has to operate today.

In any event, the next time a politician tries to convince you that private equity is bad for business just recall all the companion industries are thriving due to its model. The latest winner may be the insurers who are underwriting a majority of these deals.

The post Insurers Underwrite LBO Risk appeared first on Private Equity for Families.

Source: PE4Fams feed

Filed Under: PE4Fams feed Tagged With: PE4Fams

About Rob McCreary

Insights in Your Inbox

Get notice of new PE4Fams blog posts in your inbox. Enter your email address and click the button below.

Email Address

First Name

Last Name

By submitting this form, you are granting: CapitalWorks, LLC, Cleveland, Ohio, United States, https://capitalworks.net permission to email you. You may unsubscribe via the link found at the bottom of every email. (See our Email Privacy Policy for details.) Emails are serviced by Constant Contact.

Previous Entries

  • What Baseball Teaches You About Talent Recognition and Retention

    When pitchers and catchers report for spring training the winter of my mind officially ends. My seasonal affective disorder of endless nights fades to a new dawn of clarity and ...

  • Experts Looking At Corporate Balance Sheets

    Barron’s recently invited 10 leading financial minds to look into their crystal balls and predict how capital markets may fare in 2019. This round table is always interesting, but you ...

  • Opportunity Zones- Gimmick or Gamechanger?  

    A little-known provision of the Trump Tax Reform Act of 2017 was bipartisan support for an interesting tax incentive around investments in Opportunity Zones. This is the hottest tax dodge ...

  • Zombie Stocks Are Alive And Well

    The zombie motif was popularized by the horror movie “Night of the Living Dead” where zombies and vampires morphed into aggressive and deadly undead preying on humans. The zombie concept ...

  • China Debt- Opportunity or Contagion

    Remember when a Japanese investment group bought Pebble Beach Golf Blub September 1990? It seemed like every important asset was being gobbled up by an ascendant Japanese economy. Soon thereafter ...

PE4Fams.com
1100 Superior Avenue
Cleveland, Ohio 44114


Call us at 216.781.3233 or email us at engage@capitalworks.net.
  • Home
  • Who We Are
  • Criteria
  • Portfolio
  • News
  • Contact
  • Disclaimer
Copyright ©2019 CapitalWorks, LLC